The
Living
Archive

what the archive is about

The Living Archive explores the potential of (post)industrial heritage to transform production in our cities. We collect stories with participatory heritage methods. The nodes for the local collection efforts are Fab City Hubs (FCH). The collection has been carefully assembled by FCH teams who have been learning about, co-creating and applying participatory heritage-making approaches, emotion networking methodology, oral history principles and creative perspective-taking.
 Select tags and categories to filter stories in the archive below. Explore their connections in the network graph.

Loading stories...

European Union Logo

This project has received funding from the European Union's Horizon 2020 Research and Innovation programme under grant agreement n. 869595

Reinwardt Academy Logo

connect with CENTRINNO

Exploring emotions in the Charmilles Industrial Zone

exploring emotions in the charmilles industrial zone-hero-image

This story is about...

Subject:An Emotion Networking session in and about the ZIC

Collected in:Geneva

Using:Emotion Networking Session

Date of Events:Today

Related Locations:MACO (Collaborative Manufacture)

The emotions of industrial work

During our workshop focused on Geneva's industrial heritage, we introduced an emotion networking session centered around the Charmilles Industrial Zone (ZIC). Participants came from various professional backgrounds, all somehow linked to this area. We began by outlining the exercise's purpose and our desired outcomes.

Participants

Hello, I'm Samantha, a member of Resources Urbaines and a community member. I also have a workshop in LASIK, which I've been involved with for two years. I feel a sense of nostalgia and desire for this area. The nostalgia stems from the charm of the old streets, and the desire arises from the manual and technical aspects and the knowledge it holds. I'm Annabelle, an artist in the second workshop. I find the emotion of contradiction apt, as I have mixed feelings about the area. It's a mix of positive and negative emotions. On one hand, there's the hustle and bustle, the intensity of activity over the years, the concrete, and so on. On the other hand, there's positivity associated with the potential, space, and the spirit of collectivity and architecture. I'm Benedict, a historian. My emotions are deeply tied to the site's history. I've marked it with the words "monumental" and "noisy." These aspects of the site have captured my attention. There's also a sense of integration and repetition, creating an intense experience for me, which is generally pleasant. I work in the social-economic structure of Solidarity, as a priest, a faith-teacher of Geneva, and a structural designer. I've placed myself in the bottom left quadrant, associating all aspects with unpleasant emotions. My feelings are mixed, encompassing nostalgia for industrialization and the progress it brought, as well as the discomfort and lack of desire to return to that environment.

I'm Tristan Léry, a social worker in the neighborhood and a resident. I've chosen the term "afflicted" as my emotion because I see the impact of rapid change on the people living here. The rapid densification and housing changes are challenging for the residents. It's an unpleasant reality, but I also view it as something that we must address and adapt to.

I'm Chiara, responsible for the Agenda 21 service of the city of Geneva. I've associated the word "joy" with the intense and pleasant side of my emotions. The photos evoke memories of my initial encounters with the area and the excitement it brought. The childhood memories of the place, the workers' photo, and the idea of continuous history contribute to my intense joy.

I'm Nicole, responsible for cultural place policies in the territory department. I've used the words "nostalgia," "passion," and "memory" to describe my intense and pleasant emotions. These images remind me of a time when I was deeply involved in sociology and architecture work. It was a time of dreaming about transformations and community projects, some of which have now become a reality. I feel a strong connection to these memories, even those associated with people who have passed away.

Findings

After sharing our initial emotions and experiences related to the Charmilles Industrial Zone, let's take a moment to reflect on how our emotions might have evolved in response to what others have shared. This exercise is non-hierarchical and allows for diverse starting points and emotions, making it valuable in our quest for solutions. As you've listened to others, consider how your emotions may have shifted. Has the history or stories shared by others affected your feelings? Are your emotions now more intense or softer, more pleasant or more unpleasant? I realized that I have a nostalgic connection to the place from my childhood, and it's now in a softer and more pleasant corner for me. I marked "Creux-Equipé" on my post-it because I share the concerns and questions of the people in the area about what the future holds. It remains an unknown, and there's an ambivalence. I have mixed feelings about the past and the transformations. There's an ambivalence, but it's also important to allow the present-day transformation to occur. Inspired by the joy and positive memories shared, I've moved to the pleasant and intense side. I find it highly enjoyable to think about the potential and the ongoing history of this place. The shared memories and passion have reinforced my nostalgia and the intensity of my pleasant feelings. These places continue to hold strong emotions and memories. As we continue to reflect on our evolving emotions and experiences related to the Charmilles Industrial Zone, let's hear more from the participants: I've moved towards the pleasant side and positioned myself in the middle, feeling "serene and touched." I believe in the potential of the area and its ability to meet the needs of the local population. For those who live in the vicinity, these places may seem somewhat out of reach, and I hope that the smart minds in our community can bridge this gap and create something that benefits everyone. I've also positioned myself in the middle, reflecting on the idea of a "return to adult life." The concept of unacknowledged hardship and the challenge of neighborhood transformation resonates with me. These are complex challenges, and it's somewhat disheartening. I'm leaning towards the possible and open to new opportunities. I believe in the transformative potential of these places. The passion and courage of those involved inspire me. I'm also aware of the hardships faced by people in these areas and appreciate the idea of revitalizing them. Your reflections emphasize the complexity and potential of this area's transformation. The experiences and emotions we've shared help us envision a future where these industrial spaces can be reinvigorated and where the local community can benefit. It's a challenging yet hopeful journey. As we approach the third round of our discussion, we've contemplated how to proceed. Our project has specific objectives, and although our current conversation is free of any particular agenda, the work we do carries significant stakes. We've decided to focus on emotions and experiences rather than adding specific stakes to the discussion. For this round, we've chosen a meaningful sentence, a quote from one of the artisans, to guide our reflections. Our aim is to evoke personal experiences and emotions rather than delve into conflicts of interest or a right and wrong perspective. The sentence will serve as a catalyst for your thoughts. Take your time to reflect on how it resonates with what has been shared so far about this place or perhaps something entirely different that matters to you. I've chosen "consciousness," "confidentiality," and "action" to encapsulate my emotions. This quote reminds me of the intensity of my feelings about this industrial site. Being conscious of what happened in the past, even if it is critically viewed, is essential. Confidentiality plays a role in rehabilitation and transformation, emphasizing the importance of being together and aware. Action is vital as we transform these places in harmony with the locality and its inhabitants, highlighting the past without canceling it. My chosen emotions are "intense" and "soft." This quote reminded me of my extensive experience in collaborative and cooperative projects, particularly in the realm of biotope. The word "networks" also resonates, as it signifies the connections and collaborations that shape our lives. However, as it moves further from emotions, it becomes less emotional when we shift into a public space. This transformation is a social process that is both precious and fragile, a story of life. In this third round of our discussion, some participants found it challenging to identify specific emotions. Instead, they encountered broader concepts and ideologies that sparked their thoughts and reflections. The quote led me to contemplate a concept, rather than a distinct emotion. I found myself reflecting on the idea that places can be compared to natural biotopes and ecosystems, with a hidden synergy between the living and the precious, much like the sea. This reflection gravitated towards the concept of "eco-industrial logic." I believe that we should consider not just the physical space where activities take place but also the interactions that occur within it. This perspective can significantly contribute to urban quality and create a novel approach to protection of nature and heritage. My response was more a sense of contentment rather than a specific emotion. The quote made me reflect on the everyday moments that occur in concrete, tangible places like our lives insinuating themselves into these interactions. I thought of "constellations" as places that can mediate in the city, adapting to various contexts and taking on multifaceted roles. I had a notion of finding one's place in diversity. It's like each of us finds a niche within the fragility, supporting and connecting with others. This concept led me to think of a primitive idea of interconnectedness.

Conclusions

These reflections emphasize the depth and diversity of thought within our group. The concept of "eco-industrial logic" resonates with our efforts to revitalize this space, while the idea of "constellations" suggests adaptability and multifaceted potential. The concept of finding one's place in diversity underscores the importance of interconnectedness and shared experiences. As we continue this dialogue, we draw inspiration from your reflections and ideas, as they guide our journey towards a more vibrant and harmonious Charmilles Industrial Zone. It's clear that the workshop provided an engaging and thought-provoking experience, and it appears to have achieved its goal of promoting meaningful dialogue and reflection among participants. The process demonstrated the potential for this approach to foster both collaboration and a deeper understanding of the challenges and opportunities surrounding the Charmilles Industrial Zone. The issue of "valorization" is indeed a complex and multi-faceted one, and your concerns regarding its potential impact on the community are valid. It's crucial to explore this concept in a way that benefits the people who live and work in the area without causing harm or displacement.

Why is this story relevant?

It is an interesting exercise that showed the different relations to the heritage of the site, to its uses and the future of it.

Story and image contributed by Carolina Becker of the Geneva pilot team

Next Story

Scroll down

The trees are climbing the walls

the trees are climbing the walls-hero-image